CBS News Democratic Presidential Debate at Drake University           Saturday, November 14, 2015


O'Malley for President

Democratic National Committee

Public Policy Polling (via Correct the Record)

Republican National Committee

Republican Party of Iowa

and from the next day...

Hillary for America

CBS News


O'Malley for President
For Immediate Release:
November 14, 2015
 
Contact:
Haley Morris

STATEMENT: Hyers: O'Malley Wins Second Debate

DES MOINES, IA - Tonight, O'Malley for President Senior Strategist Bill Hyers released the following statement about Governor O'Malley's winning performance in the second Democratic debate:

"Tonight, there was one winner on stage: Governor Martin O'Malley. He showed he is ready to be Commander-In-Chief. He proved that he's the only candidate of actions and not just words. 

"In every segment of tonight's debate, Governor O'Malley had the breakthrough moment. From his story of the mom in Burlington, Iowa who told told him to always remind other public servants that soldiers aren't just 'boots on the ground,' that they're human beings, to standing up to Trump on his nativist and racist immigration policies, to showing why neither Senator Sanders nor Secretary Clinton has the backbone to stand up to the National Rifle Association, he brought the passion, principles, and fight that Democrats need in their next nominee.

"Governor O'Malley showed that he has the fresh thinking and new leadership we need to build on President Obama's legacy. He will be the Democrat's strongest candidate in November 2016. He is the best person to lead our nation." 

###


O'Malley for President

Reviews Are In: Martin O’Malley Won Second Democratic Debate

“Winner: Martin O’Malley” … “Showed He’s a True Contender Best Showing” … “Iowa Political Watchers Tell Me: Strategically, O’Malley Had the Best Performance” ... “Gave By Far the Best Democratic Debate Answer on Refugees” … “A lot of Volume Went to Martin O’Malley” … “O’Malley Had a Strong Night. Won’t Be Surprised to See Him Gain Ground” … “O’Malley Truly Torched Twitter Tonight” … “On Immigration, O’Malley is Best” … “Earned Thunderous Applause” … “Pain[ted] Himself as the Fresh Face in the Democratic Party” … “His Best Night of the Campaign to Date. Solid, Confident, and Often Lyrical”

Washington Post Headline: Winners: Martin O’Malley

Bloomberg Headline: Report Card: Clinton Opens the Door to Her Rivals: Sanders and O'Malley Step Up in Iowa Debate.

Bustle Headline: O'Malley's Debate Performance Was His Best Yet

Boston Globe Headline: Martin O’Malley’s big line of the night? Slamming Donald Trump

Baltimore Sun Headline: O'Malley takes tougher approach in second debate

Washington Examiner Headline: O'Malley calls Trump an 'immigrant-bashing carnival barker'

The Week Headline: Martin O'Malley Earns Thunderous Applause by Calling Donald Trump An 'Immigrant-Bashing Carnival Barker'

Talk Radio News Headline: O’Malley: Trump Is An ‘Immigrant-bashing Carnival-Barker’

Vox Headline: Martin O'Malley Gave, By Far, the Best Democratic Debate Answer on Refugees

Bloomberg Politics Headline: After ‘Carnival Barker’ Barb, Trump Calls O’Malley a ‘Clown’

Mic Headline: Martin O'Malley: "My Son Is Not a Pair of Boots on the Ground"

Time Headline: Watch Martin O’Malley Compare Hillary Clinton to Annie Oakley

Des Moines Register Headline: Clinton, O'Malley Spar over Minimum Wage

Politico Headline: O'Malley Got the Counter-Punch from Donald Trump He was Spoiling For

Business Insider Headline: Donald Trump snipes back after Martin O'Malley calls him a 'carnival barker' at the Democratic debate

The Hill Headline: O'Malley Slams Trump as 'Carnival barker' on Immigration

Adam Sharp (Video): “A lot of that volume went to Martin O’Malley who wound up in the double digits having been in the 1, 2, 3% range in the overall conversation.”

Gloria Berger (Video): “O'Malley was right about Hillary Clinton and Annie Oakley. Remember
that?”


Rick Unger (Video): “I thought Governor O'Malley hit on the one point that isn't discussed
enough and he went there, is our need to have more human intelligence on the ground around the world, particularly where this kind of a problem is breeding  … he hit it.”


Washington Post: “Winners: Martin O’Malley … He also showed a willingness to go at Hillary Clinton aggressively and unapologetically. And to tout his record as having accomplished many of the liberal goals that Clinton and Bernie Sanders just talk about. His riff on why candidates
shouldn't use the phrase "boots on the ground" was powerful, even if he did use an anecdote ... to make his point … taken in its totality, tonight's debate was one of the better moments for O'Malley in this race.


Bloomberg: “O’Malley B+, Clinton B, Sanders B … [O’Malley’s] best night of the campaign to date. Solid, confident, and often lyrical ... Frequently emotional and engaging on domestic policy, especially when effectively pushing his Maryland governing record and hitting Clinton hard on gun control … spoke movingly about an Iowa military family ... this performance will
rally his supporters and allow him to enter the next phase of the campaign with the potential to be more than a sidebar player.


Washington Post: “Martin O’Malley ... seemed more aggressive on Saturday night – attacking both his rivals onstage, and Republicans far off of it. He got one of the night’s biggest rounds of applause by referring to GOP front-runner Donald Trump as ‘That immigrant-bashing carnival barker’ … O’Malley drew the debate’s first sustained applause, by mentioning the Republican front-runner Democrats love to hate.”

Bustle: One contender who turned in a much better — and more aggressive — performance than in past debates was Martin O’Malley, who had his best debate night yet.

The Week: “O'Malley … got a moment in the spotlight ... with an elaborate Donald Trump ... insult, which was met with thunderous applause, ended with a hilarious mic drop.”

Bustle: O'Malley has finally found his voice during this bizarre 2016 election season. O'Malley's closing remarks at the end of the second Democratic debate were oozing with presidential charm, showing that maybe we shouldn't underestimate the under-the-radar candidate.

Talk Radio News: Martin O’Malley received his biggest applause during Saturday night’s debate for criticizing Republican presidential front-runner Donald Trump. Speaking on border security, O’Malley called for a pathway to citizenship for immigrants living in the country illegally.”

NPR: O'Malley, pain[ted] himself as the fresh face in the Democratic party.

Mic: He made a successful bid for the hearts of Iowa voters by responding to a question about his fitness as commander-in-chief with the personal story of an Iowa mother.

Business Insider:Former Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley (D) got one of the biggest applause lines of Saturday night's debate for his criticism of Republican presidential front-runner Donald Trump. Asked about border security and immigration reform, O'Malley called for a path to citizenship for immigrants living in the US illegally and slammed Trump for supposed ‘immigrant bashing.’"

Bloomberg: “O'Malley blasted the Republican party front-runner who has been calling for restrictions on immigration and deportations of people living here illegally, earning a thunderous ovation … O'Malley … argued [he’d] be tougher on the financial elites than Clinton. O'Malley ruledout Larry Summers and Robert Rubin, who served as treasury secretariesfor past Democratic presidents, from serving in his administration.”

The Hill:He bashed the GOP front-runner candidate’s immigration rhetoric … O’Malley has repeatedly sought to use immigration as a wedge issue between him and the rest of the field.”

Washington Examiner: “O'Malley touted his role in passing comprehensive gun control and went after the Vermont socialist for his 2005 vote for the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms (PLCCA) Act to give "immunity" to gun dealers.”

Time: “Martin O’Malley compared Hillary Clinton to famous female gunslinger Annie Oakley during a discussion of gun control during Saturday’s Democratic debate. The comparison came as former Maryland Gov. O’Malley accused Clinton of flip-flopping on the issue of gun control, which she now supports.”

Bleeding Heartland: O’Malley was the most-improved candidate. Compared to the first debate, he sounded less scripted and spoke more forcefully. Lots of people googled his name, especially during the first hour. O’Malley’s top moment on Twitter came when he employed a crowd-pleasing line from his stump speech, deriding Donald Trump as an "immigrant-bashing carnival barker." His problem is that Clinton and Sanders were mostly solid. I don’t see O’Malley making headway against the front-runners unless one or both make big mistakes.

USA Today:O’Malley also slammed Clinton, calling her Wall Street proposals ‘weak tea.’

Associated Press: “Former Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley paint[ed] the former senator from
New York as a lackey for Wall Street and corporate interests.”


Mark Halperin @MarkHalperin: My debate report card grades: O'Malley: B+, Sanders: B, Clinton: B. Full report cards coming soon.

Joe Trippi@JoeTrippi: .@MartinOMalley had a strong night too.  Won't be surprised to see
him gain some ground.


James Asher @jimasher: O'Malley showed he's a contender. His best showing.

Matt Viser  @mviser: Could this debate be Martin O’Malley’s breakout moment?

Courtney Crowder @CourtneyCare: Interesting takeaways from the @KCCINews focus group...O'Malley looking like a real candidate for people who didn't think of him before.

Quentin Misiag  @quentin_misiag: Iowa political watchers tell me: Strategically, @MartinOMalley had the best performance. "He finally has a seat at the table." #DemDebate

Slate@Slate: Bernie had burns, but O’Malley truly torched Twitter tonight, according
to @CBS:
http://slate.me/1kxbgmr #DemDebate

Natalie Andrews @nataliewsj: Social media buzz for Martin O'Malley was up 112% versus the last debate, per social analytics @Zoomph #DemDebate pic.twitter.com/oeoYxjLkUi

Jose Antonio Vargas @joseiswriting: Not sure. I havent studied candidates enough. On #immigration, @MartinOMalley is best. But thats just one issue.

Amanda Krenz  @ACKrenz: .@MartinOMalley the only candidate in the spin room. #DemDebate @weareiowa5news @ThisWeekInIowa pic.twitter.com/tReqTNuLOE

Gabriel Debenedetti  @gdebenedetti: One candidate is braving the spin room: @MartinOMalley pic.twitter.com/aFUr4W7Sh2

Grant Rodgers  @GrantMRodgers: "It's like being at the mall in line for Santa," cameraman remarks about trying to get to O'Malley. #DemDebate pic.twitter.com/P7v3RgcUqX

###
--
Haley Morris
Democratic National Committee
For Immediate Release
November 14, 2015
 
Contact: DNC Press

 DNC Chair Statement on Democratic Presidential Debate

DES MOINES – Democratic National Committee Chair Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz issued the following statement on the DNC/Iowa Democratic Party/CBS/KCCI/Des Moines Register Debate held at Drake University tonight:
 
“Democrats, like people the world over, woke up today with a heavy heart but proud to stand with the people of Paris and our allies across the globe in the wake of the horrific violence they experienced last night. Tonight, the American people tuned in to hear directly from three extremely qualified candidates running to be their Commander-in-Chief and build on President Obama’s legacy of bringing terrorists to justice and keeping American civilians safe.
 
“What they heard was a spirited debate, one that showed that our Democratic candidates have a firm grasp on America’s foreign policy challenges, while respecting voters and keeping the discussion at a serious and substantive level. Our candidates also showed that they are the only ones running for president who understand the importance of investing in the middle class and strengthening the economy to keep America moving forward.
 
“Our candidates are the only ones committed to making college affordable, to raising the federal minimum wage, to protecting our seniors, to fixing the broken immigration system, and to addressing climate change.
 
“Tonight provided a stark contrast from what we saw all week from the Republican field, with an embarrassing debate at which they characterized issues like raising the federal minimum wage as a ‘disaster’ and proved they are out of touch, stuck on the failed policies of the past and mired in extremism. On the economy, this week, Republican candidates offered their worn out proposals  to continue pursuing tax cuts for the wealthy, fixating on taking us back to the same kind of policies that were in place when our economy was losing 800,000 jobs a month as the last Republican president left office. And when it comes to national security and tackling terrorism, all Republicans could offer was more of the same reckless foreign policy in the vein of Dick Cheney and George W. Bush. The American people can’t afford to go backwards.
 
“I congratulate all of our candidates tonight on a debate that made me even more proud than ever to be a Democrat. Our 45th president was on stage tonight in Des Moines.”
 
###
Democratic National Committee

What folks on Twitter are saying about the #DemDebate

Tonight, each of the Democratic presidential candidates showed that they have a firm grasp on the foreign policy challenges facing our nation, and that they respect voters enough to give serious and substantive answers on what it takes to tackle terrorism across the globe. We saw our candidates offer clear solutions to important issues that will lift up the middle class and continue the progress we’ve made to keep America moving forward. Our candidates weren’t afraid of tough questions from the moderators, and they have a clear vision for how to make college more affordable, raise the federal minimum wage, protect our seniors, and fix the broken immigration system.
 
After watching the Republicans recycle failed, stale ideas at their debate on Tuesday night, the Democratic debate tonight was a breath of fresh air for Americans. The Democrats showed they are up to the task of building on the progress that President Obama has made for middle-class families. The American people can’t afford to go backwards, and tonight’s debate was a reminder we don’t have to—we can keep America moving forward.
 
Read what people are saying on Twitter below:
 
@NPRrelving: This is a policy wonk's dream! #nprdebate
 
@lexi4prez: #DemDebate: Where you can politely discuss opposing views without having to scream over eachother.
 
@NHKathySullivan: Once again I'm struck how much more serious, substantive Democratic debates r than GOP. #demdebates
 
@chris_p_harris: Last 30 mins have been more substantive than all GOP debates combined #DemDebate
 
@desmoinesdem: Listening to all candidates talk about #criminaljusticereform makes me proud to be a Democrat. #DemDebate
 
@BenjySarlin: Democrats got tough questions with instant fact checks the whole evening, yet somehow resisted urge to deliver tirade against biased media
 
@donnabrazile: #Demdebate. The Dem candidates aren’t afraid of tough questions from the moderators, and have a clear vision for the future.
 
@Ppact: All the #DemDebate candidates stand with Planned Parenthood. They’re #InOurCorner on reproductive rights and health.
 
@mcgregormt: There are some differences in this #Demdebate but it’s all substance & it’s all policy solutions. It’s such a constrast w/ the GOP debates.
Public Policy Polling (forwarded by Correct the Record)

Democratic Voters Overwhelmingly Think Clinton Won Debate; Particularly Strong on National Security Issues

A Public Policy Polling survey of Democratic primary voters nationally who watched tonight’s debate finds that it reinforced Hillary Clinton’s front runner status. Viewers overwhelmingly think she won the debate, and particularly trust her over the rest of the Democratic field when it comes to issues of national security.

Key findings from the survey include:

-67% of voters think Clinton won the debate, to 20% for Bernie Sanders and 7% for Martin O’Malley. On a related note 63% of viewers said the debate gave them a more positive opinion of Clinton, compared to 41% who said it gave them a more positive opinion of Sanders, and 37% who said it gave them a more positive opinion of O’Malley.

-Clinton is by a wide margin the candidate debate watchers trust the most on national security issues. 75% say they have the most faith in Clinton on that front, compared to only 17% for Sanders, and 5% for O’Malley. National security issues were a primary focus tonight in the aftermath of yesterday’s tragedy in France, and Democratic voters by far and away trust Clinton the most on that issue.

-What’s particularly striking is how universal the sentiment that Clinton won the debate tonight is among all the different groups within the Democratic Party. 86% of African Americans, 73% of women, 70% of moderates, 69% of seniors, 67% of Hispanics, 65% of liberals, 61% of white voters, 58% of men, and 50% of younger voters all think that Clinton was the winner of tonight’s debate.

-Overall among those who watched the debate tonight, 67% say they plan to vote for Clinton in the primary to 25% for Sanders, and 4% for O’Malley.

Clinton came into tonight’s debate as the clear front runner for the Democrats and these numbers make it clear that the debate and particularly Clinton’s strength on national security issues just reinforced her front runner status.

PPP interviewed 510 Democratic primary voters nationally by telephone after the debate who had been pre-screened on Thursday and Friday as planning to watch the debate and willing to give their opinions about it afterward. The survey’s margin of error is +/-4.3%. This research was conducted on behalf of Correct The Record.

Full results here


Republican National Committee

RNC Statement On CBS Democrat Presidential Primary Debate

WASHINGTON – RNC Chairman Reince Priebus released the following statement in response to tonight’s Democrat primary debate:
 
"In what should have been a walk in the park for Hillary Clinton, tonight’s debate reinforced that she is inconsistent on issues, weak on terrorism and beholden to special interests.

"After running to the right of President Obama in 2008, tonight Clinton continued to shift to the left on issue after issue to keep up with a seventy-four year old socialist from Vermont.

"In the shadow of yesterday’s attacks in Paris, Clinton refused to call out 'Islamic extremism' or President Obama’s failing ISIS strategy. And in a new low, Hillary Clinton shamefully hid behind the 9/11 terrorist attacks in a bizarre attempt to deflect attention from her ties to her wealthy donors.

"Tonight only reinforced why we need to send a Republican to the White House and that Hillary Clinton and the Democrats don’t have the ideas to keep America safe."
Republican Party of Iowa

Iowa GOP Statement on Democratic Debate

Good evening, please consider the following statement from the Iowa GOP on tonight's Democratic debate:

“Hillary Clinton had a disastrous night, shirking blame for her failed foreign policy's role in creating ISIS and attempting to spin away her blatant hypocrisy by invoking the attacks of 9/11. It’s too bad the DNC was able to successfully bury her failed performance on a Saturday night, when Iowans would rightly prefer to spend their time watching our University of Iowa Hawkeyes." 
-Charlie Szold, communications director

Jeff Kaufmann: Reflecting On A Somber Saturday

ICYMI: Iowa GOP Democratic Debate Travel Guide 
 
--

Charlie Szold
Communications Director 
Republican Party of Iowa

November 15, 2015

Hillary for America

#DemDebate Reviews Are In: Clinton ‘Winner,’ ‘Peerless,’ ‘Delivered,’ ‘Claimed Superior Knowledge,’ ‘Moved Undecided Iowans’

Politico: “Hillary Clinton crushed her two rivals on the commander-in-chief test during last night’s debate.”

https://ci6.googleusercontent.com/proxy/RnNZfQn2o2xpggJQqefCOervMbPIci5mujDPJnvl43kv6Rtxjyh5gHN_JKVzeU-aaGz3pePFgxfoAAtZJZNx8mveVTc-11j98EfuAJVcumUenA=s0-d-e1-ft#https://ssl.gstatic.com/ui/v1/icons/mail/images/cleardot.gif
The New Republic: Hillary Clinton Is the Peerless 2016 Candidate
“By virtue of her four year tenure as secretary of state, Clinton is just incomparably briefed on foreign affairs. In terms of sheer factual and systemic knowledge, the contrast between Clinton and the other Democratic candidates is occasionally painful.”
 
Politico: “Seventy-seven percent of Democratic insiders surveyed called Clinton the winner, saying that of the three candidates on the stage, she showed the most presidential stature.”
 
CBS News: “Immediately after Saturday night's Democratic debate, CBS News interviewed a nationally representative sample of debate watchers assembled by GfK's Knowledge Panel who identified themselves as Democrats or independents. By a 23 point margin, these debate watchers say Hillary Clinton won the debate. Fifty-one percent say Clinton won, compared to 28 percent who favor Bernie Sanders. Just 7 percent pick Martin O'Malley as the winner. Fourteen percent called it a tie.”
 
The Hill: Poll: Clinton clear winner of second debate
“Sixty seven percent of Democratic primary voters said Clinton won the debate, Public Policy Polling (PPP) found. Twenty percent thought Sen. Bernie Sanders (I- Vt.) won the debate, PPP added, while 7 percent picked former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley as the winner.”
 
USA Today: “The former secretary of State showed a command of the world scene, and she reminded the crowd that she pushed for the raid that killed Osama bin Laden.”
 
Forbes (column): Hillary Clinton Wins A Spirited Democratic Debate
“Clinton cited the battle scars of waging the fight for healthcare reform and praised her former boss, President Barack Obama, for passing the Affordable Care Act despite obstacles by Republicans in Congress.”
 
Vox: “Winner: Hillary Clinton”
“The Democratic presidential debate on CBS Saturday night was really Hillary Clinton’s to lose, and she didn’t disappoint.”
 
Politico: “In one of the better moments for Clinton, the front-runner went after the Vermont senator for his position on gun control, forcing him to review his record over and over again.”
“I know that Sen. Sanders had a different vote than I did when it came to giving immunity to gunmakers and sellers,” she said. Adding that that decision made the “gun lobby” more powerful, she added, “That was a terrible mistake,” and said that she would “love” to see Sanders join with some of her former Senate colleagues to reverse that decision.”
 
Washington Post (column): “Clinton won the debate. And, if she and her opponents keep this up, she’s almost certainly going to win the nomination.”
 
The Guardian (column): Foreign policy requires nuance, not just talking points. Hillary Clinton delivered
“It should come as no surprise Clinton’s voice on foreign policy issues was strong...For instance, when questions were asked about Islamic extremism, ISIS and America’s leadership in the region it became clear Hillary Clinton was the only candidate who expressed a functional understanding of Middle East politics…”
 
Wall Street Journal: “A focus group conducted by a Democratic strategist in Iowa during the debate showed Mrs. Clinton to be the winner. The survey gauged the feelings of 33 undecided Democrats in Des Moines, where the debate was held. A total of 23 said Mrs. Clinton won the debate; 10 said Mr. Sanders was the winner.  ‘It was clear that Clinton’s answers on terrorism, and her improved answers on domestic issues, moved undecided Iowans in striking ways,’ said the strategist, Chris Kofinis.”
 
McClatchy: “Sanders failed to deliver in small and large ways at the Democratic presidential debate Saturday that would have either cast positive attention on him or negative attention on her.  It’s a dynamic that explains why she’s pulling comfortably ahead of him in the Democratic race and likely to remain there in the critical weeks to come.”
 
Politico: “Hillary Clinton hit back at Bernie Sanders’ call for single-payer health care, invoking her past work on the issue as proof that it would not be a viable policy solution”
“I don’t think we should have to be defending it among Democrats,” she said of the 2010 Affordable Care Act, remarking that others in her party should be working to improve the legislation instead.
 
TIME: “Time and again, the former Secretary of State claimed superior knowledge and experience than Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley.”
“[Dickerson] asked each of the candidates to name a crisis they had experienced in their life that prepared them for the presidency. “Well, there are so many, I don’t know where to start,” Clinton responded, before retelling the story of her advising President Obama in the decision to launch a mission to kill Osama bin Laden.
“Her rivals could not match her.”
 
The New Republic: We Just Saw the Hillary Clinton that Republicans Will Have to Beat
“...Clinton’s performance wasn’t just about criticizing her Democratic opponents. It also was a clear preview of the campaign that Clinton is planning to run in the general election—with a message centered around bolstering the middle-class, a vigorous defense of Obama’s accomplishments, and sharp partisan attacks.”
 
New York Times“The attacks on Mrs. Clinton were notably harsher than in the first Democratic debate last month, an illustration of the growing pressure her two rivals feel to differentiate themselves as she tightens her hold on the Democratic race.”
 
Washington Post“As Sanders and O’Malley sought to score points by highlighting what they saw as mistakes by the Obama administration and its predecessors, Clinton tried to showcase the experience that she gained during four years as secretary of state, stressing repeatedly the complicated nature of global issues.”
 
 
###
 
For Immediate Release, November 15, 2015

CBS News
November 15, 2015

CBS NEWS’ DEMOCRATIC DEBATE, THE FIRST ON A BROADCAST NETWORK THIS CAMPAIGN SEASON, DELIVERS 8.55 MILLION VIEWERS

The CBS News Debate Was Saturday’s #1 Primetime Broadcast in Viewers

CBSN Draws Record 1.2 Million Streams for Debate and 2.4 Million Streams for Day

CBS News’ Democratic Debate, the first on a broadcast network this campaign season, delivered 8.55 million viewers, according to Nielsen time adjusted live plus same day fast national ratings for Nov. 14, 2015. The CBS News debate was Saturday’s #1 primetime broadcast in viewers.

CBSN set viewership records for its debate coverage, drawing 1.2 million streams across Connected TV devices, mobile and online platforms. CBSN also set full-day viewership records with 2.4 million total streams on Saturday.

The debate was broadcast live from Drake University in Des Moines, Iowa, last night on the CBS Television Network and across all CBS News platforms. John Dickerson, who was critically praised as the principal moderator, was joined by CBS News Congressional Correspondent Nancy Cordes, KCCI anchor Kevin Cooney and the Des Moines Register’s political columnist Kathie Obradovich in questioning the candidates: Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders and Martin O’Malley.

CBS News also partnered with Twitter to provide viewers with an enhanced experience that extended across the Network’s broadcast coverage and on CBSN. Twitter provided CBS News with real-time data and insights, as well as live reaction and questions from voters across the country, some of which were incorporated into the debate.

CBS News will broadcast a Republican debate from Greenville, S.C. on Feb. 13, 2016.

Follow CBS News on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and listen to podcasts at Play.it.